| Name | First Class Debut | First Class Record |
|---|---|---|
| Brighton Mugochi | 2007 | First Class Record |
| Ryan Bennett | 2001 | First Class Record |
| Tim Firth | 1987 | First Class Record |
| Paul Carey | 1946 | First Class Record |
| Sir Patrick Kingsley | 1928 | First Class Record |
| Herbert Chaplin | 1905 | First Class Record |
| Charles L. A. Smith | 1898 | First Class Record |
| Ernest Killick | 1894 | First Class Record |
| John Seneschal | 1882 | First Class Record |
| Rev Frederick Greenfield | 1876 | First Class Record |
| William Mechen | 1875 | First Class Record |
| Arthur Smith | 1874 | First Class Record |
| Charles Sharpe | 1873 | First Class Record |
| John Skinner | 1873 | First Class Record |
| Edward Pattenden | 1873 | First Class Record |
| Charles Kennedy | 1872 | First Class Record |
| L. Woodard | 1871 | |
| Harry Killick | 1866 | First Class Record |
| Henry Charlwood* | 1865 | First Class Record |
| William Hodson | 1862 | First Class Record |
| Richard Fillery | 1862 | First Class Record |
| Charles H. Smith | 1861 | First Class Record |
| Wm Woodard | 1861 | |
| Henry Stubberfield | 1857 | First Class Record |
| Charles Ellis | 1856 | First Class Record |
| John Pennikett | 1850 | First Class Record |
| W. Humphrey | 1848 | |
| John Wisden | 1846 | First Class Record |
| George King | 1846 | First Class Record |
| William Napper | 1845 | First Class Record |
| Edward Bushby | 1843 | First Class Record |
| Harry Smith | 1842 | |
| Charles Hammond | 1842 | First Class Record |
| Alfred Smith+ | 1839 | First Class Record |
| Edwin Napper | 1839 | First Class Record |
| James Hodson | 1838 | First Class Record |
| John Borrer | 1838 | First Class Record |
| George Picknell | 1835 | First Class Record |
| Charles Lanaway | 1823 | First Class Record |
* – Denotes England Test Cricketer
Please note: At various times, particularly over the last 40 years, current and former county cricketers have played for Henfield, and in one case (David Sheppard) a former England Test player. However, these have not been included because it cannot be reasonably claimed that they are Henfield players. We have tried to restrict this list to those who can be claimed with a degree of confidence as genuine Henfield players in that they have been rather more than just occasional players.